About Us

Five Corners Real Estate was started by Jonathan Lerner, our broker/owner. The building in which our Scarsdale office is located is formerly the Scarsdale – Heathcote Train Station located at the Five Corners of Scarsdale. “This great building has stood at the northwest corner of Heathcote Five Corners for the last 100 years,” said Jonathan Lerner. “Our historic depot is a piece of Scarsdale history, and we believe it’s important to honor that history.”

The former New York, Westchester and Boston (NYWB) Railroads completed a new passenger depot in Scarsdale, New York. This historic landmark, now fully renovated and occupied by Five Corners Real Estate, was built to accommodate passengers travelling from their homes in the “country” to New York City from 1912 until the train line was abandoned in 1937.


Heathcote Railway Depot in 1912 and Five Corners Real Estate in 2012

All NYWB stations were designed so passengers could only access the platforms by entering the main station buildings. This design allowed for a unique method of ticket fare collection that was only in use in the underground railways of London and Berlin at the time. “One hundred years ago, the depot was part of one of America’s most state-of-the art commuter railroads. It was designed by the firm of Reed and Stem from St. Paul, Minnesota. They designed more than 100 stations for major railroad lines during the early part of the 20th century and collaborated on the design for the famous New York City Grand Central Station,” said Lerner. “And most significant of all, of the 25 original NYWB stations in Westchester County, our Heathcote depot is one of only six still standing,” he added.

After the NYWB went out of business in 1938, the depot was unoccupied until 1941, when the possibility of reviving the railway was officially ruled out. The Village of Scarsdale acquired the property through foreclosure in 1943 and leased it out to various businesses, and the City even used it as a warehouse for storing election and road equipment.

In 1971, the Scarsdale Volunteer Ambulance Corps was formed and the building served as its headquarters. For more than 40 years, they answered the calls of residents, workers, and commuters in Scarsdale with advanced life support ambulance services before they moved to their newly-constructed site on Weaver Street.

In 2008, the depot underwent a two-year renovation project by Five Corners Real Estate. It’s listed on the Westchester County Inventory of Historic Places and is currently one of only 14 places in Scarsdale included in the county inventory.

In 2011, Five Corners Real Estate expanded into Greenwich occupying the Historic "Outdoor Traders Building" which is a landmark address in the Greenwich Central Business District.

Meet the Team